Fixed dose combinations- to prescribe or not to prescribe: a dilemma of medical profession

Mayank Prakash Nigam, Vinson L. G. Fernandes, Padmanabh V. Rataboli

Abstract


Background: Fixed dose combinations (FDCs) refer to products containing two or more ingredients used for a particular indication in a single dosage form. Prescribing FDCs has become a routine affair in medical practice. There has been increase in the irrational FDCs in the recent past by leaps and bounds. The pharmaceutical companies are luring the physicians to prescribe their products even when they are not needed by the patients. The Indian laws too are not properly defined to grant marketing approvals of FDCs. Hence the rationality of a FDC has become one of the most controversial and debatable issues in general practice.

Methods: We hence decided to analyze the existing FDCs in Indian market and study their rationality.

Results: We observed that, although many brands of FDCs available are essentially rational as per WHO and Indian essential drugs lists, the irrational FDCs easily outnumber the rational ones. Hundreds of rational FDCs are also available which are not included in WHO or Indian essential drugs lists. A few FDCs with incorrect doses were also noted. Irrational FDCs not only cause more adverse drug reactions but the antibiotic FDCs are responsible for increasing the chances of resistance. A few of these are discussed for their irrationality.

Conclusions: It is the need of the hour to raise our voice against the growing list of irrational FDCs and try to reduce the magnitude of this problem by sensitizing the undergraduates, the interns as well as the practitioners regarding their efficacy, safety, suitability, rationality and cost benefit.


Keywords


Fixed dose combinations, Drug combinations, Irrational combinations, Essential drug combinations, Rational combinations

Full Text:

PDF

References


Gautam CS, Aditya S. Irrational drug combinations: need to sensitize undergraduates. Indian journal of pharmacology. 2006;38:169-70.

N.K. Jain, A Akarte, P T Deshmukh, P Kanojia, N Gerud, Y Akash. Rationality of FDCs: An Indian Scenario. The pharma research. 2009;(1):158.

WHO model list of essential medicines 16th list. Available at: http://www.who.int/medicines/publications/essential medicines/updated sixteenth adult list en.pdf (last update March 2012).

National list of essential medicines 2003. Available at: http ://www.serowho.int/linkfiles/essential drugs and medicines india.pdf (accessed 3/8/2012).

Gulhati CM. Irrational fixed dose drug combinations: a story of profits before patients. Issues medical ethics. 2003;11:5.

R. Sweety Prem Kumar: Fixed Dose Combinations. Rational drugs. 2008Jan-June;31&32:3-9.

Expert panel on FDCs meet in Delhi. Available at: www.indswiftltd.com/view_news.php?id=826 (accessed on 12/4/2013).

Amitav. S: Indian markets fixation with FDCs (editorial) rational drug bulletin. 2002;12:1.

B G Jayasheel. Regulatory requirements for marketing FDCs. Perspect Clin Res. 2010;1(4):120-3.

Chakraborti A. Prescription of FDC drugs for diarrhea. Indian Journal of medical Ethics. 2007;4:165-7.

C.S Gautam, L. Saha. FDCs- rational or irrational: a view point. British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology. 2008May;65(s):795-6.

Sreedhar D. Menthan D, Jawodia, V.S Ligade, S Mohapatra, R Ganguly, N.V Dupa. FDCs: rational or irrational? Current status. 2008;95(5):581-3.

Gulhati CM: Monthly Index of Medical Specialities, India. 2005;25:81-94.

Burke A, Smyth E, Gerald GAF. Analgesic- antipyretic agents; pharmacotherapy of gout. Goodman and Gilman’s: The Pharmacological basis of Therapeutics. New York. McGraw- Hill; Jadav Sp, Parmen DM. critical appraisal of irrational drug combinations: a cell for awareness in undergraduate medical students. Journal of pharmacotherapy. 2011;2:45-8.

Soll AH. Medical treatment of peptic ulcer disease: practical guidelines. JAMA. 1996;275:622.

Sweetman S.C. (editor) Lactic acid producing organisms. Martindale- the complete drug Reference, 35th edition. Pharmaceutical press. 2007.

Main PL, LJ. Levocetirizine: a review of its use in the management of allergic rhinitis and skin allergies. Drugs. 2006;66:973-96

Alex J. India may ban sale of flupenthixol melitracen combination drug. Pharmacological convention. 2013Jan17.

On target investigators, Yusuf S, Teo KK, Pogue J, Dyel L, Coplain L , et al. Telmisartan, ramipril, or both in patients at high risk for vascular events. New England Journal of Medicine. 2008;258:1547-59.

Peuda J, Tiwari P, Uppal R. evaluation of the rationality of some FDCs: focus on antihypertensive drugs. Indian Journal of Pharmacology. 2006;68:649-53.

Diener HC, Bogousslausky J, Brass LM, Cimminello C, Lsibn L, Kaste M, Leys D, Metins- Guriu J, Rupprecht. Lancet. 2004;24:331.

More PM, Michel B. Is the FDC of telmisartan and HCTZ a good approach to treat hypertension? Vascular health and risk management. 2007:265-78.

Bhattacharya SK, Sen P, Roy A, Pharmacology, Elsevier, New Delhi 2. 2003:561-5.

Anastasios M, Maria S, Dimitris PP. Resistant hypertension workup and approach to treatment. International Journal of Hypertension. 2011; 2011:1-10.

Osvaldo K, Wilte O, Decio N, Joao CR, Marco AMG, Natalino S, Gilson SF, Ernesto D, Artur BR. The “LOTHAR” study: Evaluation of efficacy and tolerability of the FDC of Amlodipine and Losartan in the treatment of essential hypertension. Arquivas de Cardiologia. 2006;1:86.

Frishman W, Burnis JF, Mrocek WJ, Weir MR, Atemayehu D, Simmon 15, Chensy, Bryzinski BS. Journal of Clinical Pharmacology. 1995;35:182.

Benetos A, Adamopados C, Argyriadis P, Been K, Consoli S, Safar MJ. Hypertension. 2002;20:521.

Stone Malacio, Nob HCR. FDC for effective antihypertensive therapy. High blood pressure cardiovascular prevention. 2008;15(2):25-84.

Rational use of medicines. Good pharmacy practice I.P.A. C.D.S.C.O.- W.H.O India office. Available at: http://www.whoindia.org/lintfiles/GPP Rational use of medicines.pdf (Accessed on 3/8/2010).

F. Pan, M.E. Chernew, A Mark Fendrick. Impact of FDC drugs on adherence to prescription medications. J. Gen Internal Med. 2008;23(5):611-4.

Sreedhar O, Subramanian G, Udipa N. combination drugs are they rational? 2006;91:406.

Podolsky SH, Greene JA. Combination drugs- Hype and hope: New England Journal of Medicine. 2011;356(6):488-91.

Glasgow RE, Lichtenstein E, Mercus AC. Why don’t we see more translation of health promotion research to practice? Rethinking the efficacy to effectiveness transition. American Journal of Public Health. 2003;93(8):1261-7.